I came upon this site claiming atheism is a religion via atheism.about.com. Anyway, the site claims:
But this [that atheism is not a religion] is like saying that “black,” (which physicists define as the total absence of color) is not a color. The car I drive is a big, old Chevrolet, whose color is black. In common practice throughout the world, “black” is understood to be a color, despite the technical definition of the physicists. Likewise, “Atheism” is a religion, despite any technical definitions to the contrary.
If black is a color, then Atheism is a religion.
The analogy is flawed. The answer is clear when you think about it the right way. What color is a window?
Yes, black is a color, but atheism is still not a religion.
So, I decided to send an e-mail to the webmaster (which is pretty much what I said up here). It’s subject is “Concerning the absence of color” and it reads:
Dear Rev. Bill McGinnis,
In your web page titled “The Religion of Atheism” (found at http://patriot.net/~bmcgin/atheismisareligion.html) you state:
“But [saying atheism is not a religion] is like saying that “black,” (which physicists define as the total absence of color) is not a color. The car I drive is a big, old Chevrolet, whose color is black. In common practice throughout the world, “black” is understood to be a color, despite the technical definition of the physicists. Likewise, “Atheism” is a religion, despite any technical definitions to the contrary.
If black is a color, then Atheism is a religion.”
I believe your analogy is incorrect. An object that is transparent, such as a window, can be said to lack color.
If you believe I am incorrect, please reply. If you believe that I am correct, could you please e-mail me if you decide to make any changes to the aforementioned web page.
Thank you for taking the time to read this e-mail.
I’ll keep you updated if he decides to e-mail back.
Sorry, I just now read your article commenting on my article about “absence of color.” Your analogy is imperfect, because “clear” is not commonly understood to be a color, but “black” is. My point is that atheism is a religion, just as black is a color – despite all claims to the contrary. And I stand by that claim. Blessings to you. – Bill McGinnis